Local SportsContestsEvents

Court Rules Letter on Yankees Sign Stealing Should be Unsealed

A Federal Appeals court has shot down the Yankees request that a letter alleging the Bronx Bombers were complicit in their own sign stealing scandal back in 2017 should remain…

Brian Cashman, Yankees

WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA – MARCH 12: New York Yankees general manager Brian Cashman talks on the phone prior to a Grapefruit League spring training game between the Washington Nationals and the New York Yankees at FITTEAM Ballpark of The Palm Beaches on March 12, 2020 in West Palm Beach, Florida. Many professional and college sports are canceling or postponing their games due to the ongoing threat of the Coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak. (Photo by Michael Reaves/Getty Images)

A Federal Appeals court has shot down the Yankees request that a letter alleging the Bronx Bombers were complicit in their own sign stealing scandal back in 2017 should remain sealed. Instead that letter will now go public, according to ESPN. That letter is about two weeks away from becoming public.

According to NJ.com on Monday, the Yankees had said the letter from Commissioner Rob Manfred to General Manager Brian Cashman would, "wreck the team’s reputation, and that the letter should never have been introduced to the court in the first place since they weren’t part of the initial lawsuit."

The letter accuses the Yankees of doing more than just improperly using a dugout phone in 2017 around the same time of the Boston Red Sox.

From NJ.com: "The court also upheld the dismissal of a $5-million lawsuit DraftKings player Kristopher Olson filed with more than 100 other plaintiffs against MLB, the Houston Astros and the Boston Red Sox over the illegal sign-stealing scandal that rocked the sport over the winter of 2019-2020.

"A U.S. District Court judge had initially ordered the release of the letter, but the Yankees argued against it. It took the appeals court more than a year to rule against the team.
"The original suit, which was originally dismissed in April 2020, alleged that MLB, the Astros and the Red Sox were liable for the money DraftKings bettors lost during games Houston and Boston may have cheated."
During the Apple Watch Scandal, the Red Sox were heavily fined for using the device to steal and relay signs. The Yankees received - at the time - a smaller fine for mishandling the use of the dugout phone.
This week the judge argued that the Yankees argument that the letter would sully its reputation "carries little weight," and that it is time for the public to see the document and  "... assess MLB’s conclusion regarding the internal investigation (as articulated to the Yankees), and the Yankees are fully capable of disseminating their own views regarding the actual content of the Yankees Letter. In short, any purported distortions regarding the content of the Yankees Letter can be remedied by the widespread availability of the actual content of this judicial document to the public, and the corresponding ability of MLB and the Yankees to publicly comment on it.”
Last season when the Yankees and Astros played one another at Yankees Stadium for the first time in front of fans since the COVID-19 pandemic, fans booed and mocked the Astros for garbage can-sign stealing scandal that took place during that 2017 season, and didn't come to light until the end of the 2019 season.
Michael Cohen is the News and Sports Director at Fox Sports Radio New Jersey and Magic 98.3 FM, as well as a radio production assistant with Fox and Magic in New Jersey. He started his career in Somerset in 2018 initially as a news fill-in at WCTC 1450 AM, and soon moved up to higher responsibilities in the ensuing years, assuming News & Sports Director title in 2021Prior to his time with Fox Sports New Jersey, Michael was play-by-play voice for New Jersey Jackals baseball, and as well as play-by-play and color for the College of Staten Island basketball (men and women), softball and baseball. Michael began his career as a news and sportswriter with the Jersey Journal of Hudson County.